🔁 Fixed vs. Flexible Assignments in Public Transport: Differences, Advantages, and When to Use Each

One of the most critical planning decisions in public transport operations is how to assign drivers and vehicles.Should you stick to fixed (assigned) pairings, or adopt a more flexible, dynamic structure?

This blog explores both approaches—known in some systems as zimmetli (fixed/assigned) and zimmetsiz (unassigned/flexible)—to help you choose the best strategy for your operation.

🔒 What Is a Fixed Assignment?

In a fixed assignment structure, a driver is regularly paired with the same vehicle and/or route as part of the planning system.

📈 Key Benefits:

• Increased ownership: Drivers feel responsible for a specific bus or line, leading to better care and performance.

• More predictable maintenance: Consistent usage enables regular check-ups and cleaner operation.

• Easier tracking and feedback: Complaints, satisfaction, and performance metrics can be monitored at the individual level.

• Route familiarity: Drivers become specialists on specific lines, improving service quality and reliability.

⚠️ Possible Drawbacks:

• Limits flexibility—unexpected changes (sick leave, vehicle breakdowns) require manual intervention.

• Harder to manage in large fleets or complex shifts.

• Onboarding new drivers or rotating personnel may become challenging.

🔄 What Is a Flexible Assignment?

In this approach, drivers and vehicles are assigned dynamically for each shift or day, with no fixed pairings in the plan.

📈 Key Benefits:

• High flexibility: Allows for rapid adjustments in case of absences or emergencies.

• Operational efficiency: Assignments are based on shift needs rather than fixed pairings.

• Automation-friendly: Software like Cermoni can optimize assignments daily using algorithms.

• Fewer disruptions from unexpected events.

⚠️ Possible Drawbacks:

• Less sense of vehicle ownership among drivers.

• Route learning and consistency may decrease.

• Complaints or performance tracking become more generalized.

🧭 When to Choose Fixed vs. Flexible?

Operational Context	Recommended Approach
Small fleet, few drivers	Fixed Assignment
Large fleet, multiple shifts	Flexible Assignment
Rural/low-density area	Fixed Assignment
High-traffic, urban network	Flexible Assignment
Long-term driver-line consistency needed	Fixed Assignment
High staff turnover or dynamic workforce	Flexible Assignment

🔧 Cermoni Supports Both Models

Cermoni’s planning tools are designed to support both fixed and flexible assignment models.

• For fixed systems: Assign long-term driver-vehicle-route pairings for consistent planning.

• For flexible systems: Use optimization tools to dynamically assign the best driver and vehicle for each shift.

Regardless of your structure, the key is aligning your assignment strategy with your operational goals and constraints.

📊 Fixed or flexible—optimize your assignments with data-driven planning. Discover how Cermoni can support your operations.

Contatc Us